Former Vallejo Police Chief Andrew Bidou poses for a picture with officers Matthew Komoda, David McLaughlin and Kevin Barreto on April 29, 2016. Over the next two-and-a-half years, Komoda would participate in three shootings, McLaughlin in two, and Barreto in one.
Former Vallejo Police Chief Andrew Bidou poses for a picture with officers Matthew Komoda, David McLaughlin and Kevin Barreto on April 29, 2016. Over the next two-and-a-half years, Komoda would participate in three shootings, McLaughlin in two, and Barreto in one. Credit: City of Vallejo

In May 2019, as the Vallejo Police Department was embroiled in controversy for excessive force allegations, including shooting a sleeping person 55 times, the department held an awards and promotion ceremony at the Foley Cultural Center. One of the officers recognized was Officer Zachary Jacobsen, who was promoted to corporal. 

Just six months earlier, the City of Vallejo paid $50,000 to settle a civil rights lawsuit that alleged Jacobsen and three other officers beat a suicidal man in 2015, breaking his ankle and leg. Meanwhile another potentially costly lawsuit was pending, for the fatal shooting of 21-year-old Angel Ramos.

A department review found that Jacobson didn’t follow policy when he shot Ramos without activating his body-worn camera. Still, he faced no discipline. In fact, a critical incident review board credited Jacobsen with saving the victim’s life.

But the body camera video would have proved useful as Jacobsen’s account of the shooting differs from other witnesses — including his own partner’s. 

The officers had responded to a fight between several relatives at a family party. They approached the home from behind a fence while the fight was happening on a balcony 50 feet away. Jacobsen’s partner, Officer Matthew Samida, testified in a deposition in the family’s lawsuit that the balcony was dimly lit and their view was obstructed by a tree. In a separate deposition, Jacobsen described the scene as well-lit. 

Samida Tased a man on the deck, who fell to the floor. Ramos got on top of the man after he fell. Samida testified that he saw Ramos punch him. Jacobsen said that Ramos was making stabbing motions, so he shot him. Ramos was killed. The man had not been stabbed. No knife was found near Ramos’s body.

In February 2018, the district attorney found that Jacobsen had not broken the law. In August 2018, the department determined he would not be disciplined. In May 2019, he was promoted.

Jacobsen’s story is not unusual in Vallejo. The department has consistently declined to discipline or re-train officers who use deadly force. Open Vallejo reviewed the results of 24 internal investigations into police shootings or other use of force incidents that took place in the past decade. None resulted in discipline.

In fact, these officers are frequently rewarded: of 45 officers whose actions over the last decade have led to monetary payouts in civil rights lawsuits, all but 15 have been promoted or received an award since the incident, according to an analysis of police and court records by Open Vallejo.

The Vallejo Police Department did not respond to a request for comment.

Civil Rights Payouts vs. Awards and Promotions, 2010-2020

Sean Kenney5$2,550,0002Yes
Kenny Park1$2,500,0001
Mat Mustard1$2,500,0002Yes
Dustin Joseph3$2,070,0004Yes
Mark Thompson3$290,0002
Waylon Boyce1$235,0001
Robert DeMarco1$175,000
Kevin Bartlett2$167,5001
Jeremy Huff1$160,0001Yes

Patterns and practices

Some of Vallejo’s most decorated officers have also been involved in its costliest civil rights cases.

An internal review found that two officers who shot Mario Romero in 2012 had acted within policy, even though Officer Sean Kenney took himself out of cover and jumped on the hood of Romero’s car. The department also took no issue with the fact that Kenney and his partner, Dustin Joseph, fired on Romero 31 times. The officers alleged that Romero was armed, but only a pellet gun was found wedged in a car seat. Vallejo settled a lawsuit for $2 million on July 1, 2015. 

Neither officer was disciplined. In fact, since the shooting, they were two of the department’s most decorated officers.

Romero was one of three people Kenney killed in 2012. After that, Kenney was transferred to investigations, where he led probes into officer-involved shootings. He was also assigned to the SWAT team and placed in special assignments. He was promoted to corporal and on April 27, 2017, was awarded a Good Conduct Medal and a Medal of Merit.

Joseph also went on to have a decorated career in Vallejo. He was promoted to corporal on Jan. 11, 2014. He received A Good Conduct Medal and a Life Saving Medal that same year and was named the Vallejo Rotary Club’s Officer of the Year on Feb. 1, 2016. He received another Medal of Merit on April 26, 2018. 

Both officers recently left the department. Kenney founded his own company, Line Driven Strategies LLC, and teaches de-escalation training to officers across California. Joseph left the department shortly after Kenney and went to work for Line Driven Strategies as well.

Promoting violence

In other cases, officers engaged in serious allegations of misconduct have risen to command positions within the department.

On Dec. 11, 2010, Officer Kent Tribble shot Guy Jarreau Jr., a Napa Valley Community College student, while he was filming an anti-violence music video. Police said that they received a report of a man brandishing a gun outside a tattoo parlor. When they arrived, Jarreau allegedly fled into a nearby alley and confronted Tribble with a gun. 

But a lawsuit filed by Jarreau’s mother in 2012 alleges police ordered the entire film crew to the ground. Jarreau was already walking toward the alley when Tribble, who was not in uniform, shot Jarreau. He had his hands in the air and was holding only a green cup, according to the lawsuit.

The city settled the case  in 2017 for $49,000. Tribble was promoted to sergeant on Feb. 9, 2013, and received a Life Saving Medal and a Good Conduct Medal on May 29, 2014. Months later, he was involved in a bar fight in Bend, Oregon, where he drew a gun. 

Despite this, Tribble was promoted again to lieutenant. He received a Medal of Merit on April 26, 2018, and remains a member of the Police Department’s command staff.

Detective Mat Mustard was named Officer of the Year in 2015. That year, he investigated a bizarre kidnapping when a man broke into a couple’s home, tied them up, drugged them, and kidnapped the woman. While she was missing, Mustard interrogated her boyfriend and accused him of killing her. 

The kidnapping sparked a massive search and national headlines. When the woman turned up alive, the department called a press conference where spokesperson Lt. Kenny Park accused them of faking the kidnapping and demanded an apology. But the FBI later found and arrested the perpetrator, Matthew Muller. He pleaded guilty to kidnapping the woman in 2016 and was sentenced to 40 years in federal prison.

The couple sued the department and reached a $2.5 million settlement in 2018, the most costly civil rights settlement for Vallejo in the past decade. But even though Mustard botched the department’s highest-profile investigation in years, he was singled out as its best officer.

Mustard continued to enjoy a charmed career. He received a Good Conduct Medal on April 27, 2017, and was promoted to sergeant on Sept. 15, 2018. Until this year, Mustard headed the Vallejo Police Officers Association, an influential position where his role included negotiating the employment contract for all Vallejo police officers.

Park, meanwhile, remained public information officer for years after the incident. He received a Good Conduct Medal on April 26, 2018.


Melissa Nold, a civil rights attorney working on several lawsuits against the Police Department, said the pattern of Vallejo officers receiving rewards and promotions after controversial incidents exemplifies an obstinate culture in the department about its high rate of shootings, violence by officers, and extraordinary civil rights payouts. 

Nold pointed to the shooting of Ronell Foster by Officer Ryan McMahon in 2018. Foster had been riding a bicycle without a light and ran after police began following him in a patrol car. McMahon chased him and killed him after a struggle in a backyard. Foster was unarmed. McMahon was cleared of criminal charges and internal discipline in January. While those investigations were still pending, McMahon was one of six officers who shot and killed 20-year-old Willie McCoy after he fell asleep in his car at a Taco Bell drive-through.

After the Foster shooting, the police officers association praised a comment on Facebook saying that Foster “got what he deserved.” 

In this screenshot from February, 2020, a spokesperson for the Vallejo Police Officers' Association appeared to ratify statement by a third party that Ronell Foster "got what he deserved" when he was killed on Feb. 13, 2018.

“They took the position that somehow the person should have been dead because they ran from the police, which obviously is not a death penalty offense,” Nold said. “Their position is the officers are heroes when they hunt people down and shoot them.” 

Scott Morris is an independent journalist in Oakland and San Francisco covering police use of force, civil rights, protest and neighborhood news. In 2020 he was a reporter with ProPublica's Local Reporting Network based at the Bay City News Foundation.